
All of the broken toys went straight to the trash. I then went through and took out the toys that I thought were never played with. A tip that worked for me: Take these toys and put them in a box in the garage for a week. Wait and see if your kids mention any of the toys. If you get a “Hey Mom, have you seen my black Spiderman figure?”, discreetly pluck it from the box. If they don’t say anything, they’re none the wiser and send ’em all to Goodwill!
All of the keepers were put in two big baskets that perfectly fit in my coat closet. One basket holds all of the dress-up stuff: costumes, lightsabers, and Nerf guns. The other holds miscellaneous toys like Little People toy sets and footballs.

Feels good to have a hold on the toy situation for now! How do you deal with your kids’ toys? Please share your tips and tricks!